Re: Chat Room Comments

Since now everyone at College Park is up in arms,
let me defend what I said, because I still believe
it:

I did not think fielding a strong house team was
right. I still don't. If the players on your team
absolutely NEED to hear as many questions as is possible,
then have them playtest.

I will grant that
Maryland had an overload of staff, and that people needed
to do something that dayand hadn't heard the
questions yet. I guess my bigger complaint is not that
Maryland entered house teams -- a tradition at the
Terrapin -- but that they officially won the thing. House
teams are around because there was a spot that needed
to be filled -- not because they are bent on
winning. For reasons I'll explain in a later post, house
teams have an inherent advantage over everyone else.
For that reason, they should not be an official team.
If it's all freshmen, fine -- they do not have the
Inherent Advantage I will discuss. But experienced house
players do.

I said that it took two teams to beat
Chicago. I hold to that statement. Why? For the same
reason an experienced house team does better than it
should: the Inherent Advantage. This time, it was the
Second Manifestation.

For purposes of space, I
will discuss both Inherent Advantages separately and
away from this post. In closing, though, let me say
this: I DO know members (past and present) of the
Maryland team.

Andy

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.4.0: Sat 12 Feb 2022 12:30:42 AM EST EST