Re: [quizbowl] The Recent Debate

A simple solution, if somewhat radical, would be to change the category 
distribution.  Instead of
4 history,
4 lit,
4 science,
...

suppose it looked something more like:

5 biography
4 events
3 things (animate and inanimate but not people)
2 places
3 documents
1 idea
1 word
1 formula
...

The numbers of course are just illustrative (someone could do a sample 
of recent tournaments and see what kind of distribution is typical).  
Science, history, lit are of course important and the way things are 
studied in school, but they are not necessarily the way things are 
stored in the brain. Some people like bio (people who like people), 
some like places, some like vocabulary, some like works of creation.  
Some cross-check to ensure that not everything was lit related or 
science etc. would be important, just as we cross-check now to ensure 
not everything is 20th century or Canadian.

Just some red meat for the wolves.

-- dml

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.4.0: Sat 12 Feb 2022 12:30:47 AM EST EST