Who Owns QB Questions? (Pt 1 of 1)

This is actually interesting enough question from
a legal standpoint to maybe make it onto some
professor's Copyright Law exam. :)

My first instinct
says individuals donated them to their oragnizations,
who donated them to the host program. However, there
have been tournaments (some iterations of Penn Bowl,
esp. anything Pat Matthews had anything to do with)
that have seen fit to stipulate that _teams_ owned the
questions by default, and that Penn's organization "bought"
them with an entry fee discount. 

The original
writers of the questions in most cases have never
_explicity_ assigned their rights to any other party,
including their organizations. The practical problem with
that approach would be that individual writing credits
tend to disappear in the mists of time. Not to mention
that it is the presumed duty of editors from the host
school to in many cases make material changes to the
content of the material. 

The programs and/or
teams have a claim as well, since they compiled it and
submitted it with no explicit assignment of their
copyrights. Although the problem here is that the legal
status of "Michigan B" or even "Maryland Academic Quiz
Team" is a bit nebulous at best and dicey at worst.


The Stanford-based entity that runs the archive might
make the case that _it_ holds the copyrights unless
otherwise stipulated. However, they, unlike host schools,
do nothing to "create" the questions and have
generally received no consideration for them.

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.4.0: Sat 12 Feb 2022 12:30:43 AM EST EST