Accepting evolution on blind faith is no less foolish than accepting creationism on blind faith. Maybe there's a different explanation - other than evolution and other than creationism - for why things are the way they are. By saying that evolution is "it", you close your eyes and put your hands over your ears. Science is based upon making theories, testing them out, and seeing what parts of the theory work out and which don't. If you follow Kuhn or Imre Lakatos, no theory is ever truly disproven. If you follow Karl Popper, no theory is ever truly proven. Unless you can present me with incontrovertible proof that evolution is the way it is, I'll address the issue with an understanding that this may not be the way things actually are - I may base certain assumptions in my actions around it, but I won't consider it a law. There is nothing wrong with a question on creation science that asks questions based on scientific principles. As has been mentioned, questions exist on competing theories. As long as one does not degenerate into "bad science", such questions would appear perfectly acceptable - unless you've ever run a tournament that forbids questions on Newtonian mechanics since Einstein appears to be "righter". The assumption that things exist the way they are solely because of an involved higher power is as perfectly legitimate an original assumption as the idea that things exist the way they are because of chance. While I'd feel free to question those who present poorly-thought out theories or who just say "because" when asked for a reason, I'd caution against rejecting the assumption out of hand. Finally, Matt - it's just a debate. Quizbowl offers very little "wiggle room" as to whether an answer is correct or not. The real world isn't like this. Engage others in debate rather than cutting it off - if you are correct, you may get some people to change their minds. If nothing else, you'll get a workout in making sure that you understand what you say you believe.
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.4.0: Sat 12 Feb 2022 12:30:44 AM EST EST