Re: Dead White Males problem (1)

I guess the real question is, will adding things
that no one knows at first to the distribution help at
all? I suppose it did in the case of Norse mythology,
as mentioned, but I suspect what would happen is
you'd get a lot of griping for a while until people
finally clued in that these weren't going to go
away.

In other words, you'd need a concerted effort to
ignore the gripes and start introducing these sorts of
questions. On the one hand, this is a good idea - on the
other, I think it may actually encourage listing
somewhat.

Think about it - you're talking about subjects most
people generally don't know about (for many reasons,
although most notable of which is they're just not really
taught in schools unless you intentionally seek it out -
maybe a sad statement of fact, but something that just
has to be dealt with). So if these subjects start to
come up, are they going to go into in-depth research
on the myriad names that might come up - or are they
going to memorize a list and some facts? I'm pretty
sure I'd be more encouraged to do that than anything
else.

If you're willing to sacrifice the listing factor
for just getting these different questions in, I say
go for it - and to be sure, not everyone will list.
But just like with Norse mythology, only a handful of
people will probably be really inspired into a deep,
researched knowledge of the subject - the rest will find
some reference book. That's my two cents.

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.4.0: Sat 12 Feb 2022 12:30:45 AM EST EST