Difference between revisions of "Chicago Open Trash Tournament"
Andrew Hart (talk | contribs) |
Andrew Hart (talk | contribs) |
||
Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
== The Tournaments == | == The Tournaments == | ||
− | + | {| border="1" cellspacing="0" | |
− | + | ! Year | |
− | + | ! Tournament name | |
− | + | ! Writers/editors | |
− | + | ! Winning team | |
− | + | ! Stats | |
− | + | |- | |
− | + | | 2005 | |
− | + | | Mordechai Richler Trash Tournament | |
− | + | | [[Andrew Yaphe]] | |
− | + | | [[Ezequiel Berdichevsky]], [[Matt Lafer]], [[Paul Litvak]], and [[Matt Weiner]] | |
− | + | | n/a | |
− | + | |- | |
− | + | | 2006 | |
− | + | | Gottfried Keller Open | |
− | + | | [[Andrew Yaphe]] and [[Ezequiel Berdichevsky]] | |
− | + | | [[Greg Sorenson]], [[Brian Hight]], [[Jeremy White]], and [[Mike Burger]] | |
+ | | [http://bowl.uchicago.edu/results/Keller06stats_standings.html Stats] | ||
+ | |- | ||
+ | | 2008 | ||
+ | | Erik Axel Karlfeldt Memorial Open | ||
+ | | [[Andrew Yaphe]] (head editor), [[David Seal]] and [[Michael Arnold]] | ||
+ | | [[Greg Sorenson]], [[Brian Hight]], [[Colby Burnett]], and [[Jeremy White]] | ||
+ | | n/a | ||
+ | |- | ||
+ | | 2009 | ||
+ | | Ferdinand Tonnies Memorial Trash Tournament | ||
+ | | [[Andrew Yaphe]] (head editor), [[David Seal]], [[Michael Arnold]], and [[Mike Sorice]] | ||
+ | | [[Greg Sorenson]], [[Brian Hight]], [[Colby Burnett]], and [[Jeremy White]] | ||
+ | | n/a | ||
+ | |- | ||
+ | | 2010 | ||
+ | | Ferdinand Tonnies Memorial Trash Tournament | ||
+ | | [[Michael Arnold]] with help from [[Susan Ferrari]], [[Auroni Gupta]], [[Andrew Yaphe]] and Sam Medley | ||
+ | | [[Greg Sorenson]], [[Brian Hight]], [[Colby Burnett]], and [[Jeremy White]] | ||
+ | | [http://bowl.uchicago.edu/goodman/goodmanplayoffs_standings.html Stats] | ||
+ | |- | ||
+ | | 2011 | ||
+ | | COLT | ||
+ | | [[Mike Bentley]] | ||
+ | | [[Brian Hight]], [[Colby Burnett]], [[Jeremy White]], and a mysterious individual identified only as "[[Jimmy?]]" | ||
+ | | [http://www.hsquizbowl.org/db/tournaments/596/stats/combined/ Stats] | ||
+ | |- | ||
+ | | 2013 | ||
+ | | Seth Teitler Presents: An Intimate Engagement with Trash | ||
+ | | [[David Seal]], [[Brian McNamara]], Owen Cooper, and [[Nolan Esser]] | ||
+ | | [[Brian Hight]], [[Colby Burnett]], and [[Yogesh Raut]] | ||
+ | | [http://www.hsquizbowl.org/db/tournaments/1545/stats/trash_side_event_-_all_games/standings/ Stats]] | ||
+ | |- | ||
+ | | 2016 | ||
+ | | Chicago Open Trash | ||
+ | | [[Rob Carson]], [[Carsten Gehring]], and [[Andrew Hart]] | ||
+ | | [[Mike Cheyne]], [[Tejas Raje]], [[Kenji Golimlim]], and [[Chris Manners]] | ||
+ | | [http://www.hsquizbowl.org/db/tournaments/3795/stats/combined/ Stats] | ||
+ | |} | ||
== Style == | == Style == |
Revision as of 08:09, 31 July 2016
In recent history, the Sunday following the Chicago Open has featured a trash tournament.
The Tournaments
Style
The Chicago Open Trash tournament has brought about the development of the term-of-art "Yaphe trash" after the name of the usual driving force. Though each iteration of the tournament has been slightly different because of the various collaborators, tournaments have reflected the core principles of Yaphe trash:
- Meta quizbowl. Much to the chagrin of the some of the TRASH people who show up to the tournaments, questions about quizbowl events and individuals join meta clues in regular tossups.
- Academic content. Yaphe trash contains a higher proportion of academic content in questions. This manifests itself occasionally as trash clues about academic subjects, academic clues about otherwise trashy subjects or just plain academic questions. Curiously, in 2008 this proved more controversial among academic players than among the so-called "TRASH people," who more or less shrugged it off.[1]
- High proportion of "other" questions outside the Big 3 of trash of Sports, Music and Film/TV. Literature questions are much better represented than in TRASH or other trash tournaments while other pet topics of editors frequently come up (fashion, for example). This also allows for multidisciplinary clues to be used in common-link questions, which are themselves well-represented in Yaphe trash. Some claim the "other" distribution stints video games or other fields, while some claim it means the Big 3 are relatively underrepresented.
Commentary
While Matt Weiner has referred to the first two events and the two Maryland trash tournaments head-edited by Mike Bentley as the only four good trash tournaments ever produced, others, such as Greg Sorenson, have alleged that the Chicago tournaments featured even more 1980s content than trash usually does, notably in music. The 2008 edition was met with somewhat more praise from the usual TRASH people.