Difference between revisions of "Speed-check"

From QBWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page with ''''Speed-check''' questions are very short questions which teams buzz in on. Such questions are rarely pyramidal due to their length. Speed-check questions often appear in [[…')
 
Line 1: Line 1:
'''Speed-check''' questions are very short questions which teams buzz in on. Such questions are rarely [[pyramidal]] due to their length. Speed-check questions often appear in [[lightning rounds]].
+
'''Speed-check''' questions are very short questions in quizbowl, usually one sentence or less than a line in length. Such questions are rarely [[pyramidal]] due to their length and are usually considered (especially when sloppily written) [[bad quizbowl]].  
  
If all teams get to buzz on speed check questions, speed-checks are inherently [[bad quizbowl]] because they do not allow for players that know more about the topic to demonstrate that they know more by buzzing earlier. As the name implies, speed-check questions often reward the winner of a [[buzzer race]] rather than the player who recognized a fact first, a frustrating experience which occurs far less frequently when there are multiple clues to distinguish all players.
+
Notable users of speed-check questions include [[Questions Galore]] and many televised programs, such as [[Battle of the Brains]] and [[It's Academic]].
  
Notable users of speed-check questions include [[Questions Galore]] and several televised programs, such as [[Battle of the Brains]] and [[It's Academic]].
+
==Examples of Speedchecks==
 +
 
 +
Speed-checks are usually [[bad quizbowl]] because they do not allow for players that know more about the topic to demonstrate that they know more by buzzing earlier. As the name implies, speed-check questions often reward the winner of a [[buzzer race]] rather than the player who recognized a fact first, a frustrating experience which occurs far less frequently when there are multiple clues to distinguish all players. For instance, a speed-check might go:
 +
 
 +
Name the 39th President of the United States.
 +
 
 +
or
 +
 
 +
Who wrote ''The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn''?
 +
 
 +
These questions would both likely be considered [[bad quizbowl]] speed-checks. The former is due to asking about a relatively trivial fact rather than anything important about the actual life or presidency of George H.W. Bush, the latter due to not differentiating between players who have more knowledge of the material. In fact, a player who knows that there are other books that begin with "The Adventures of" (say, ''The Adventures of Augie March'') might easily lose a buzzer race to a player who reflex-buzzed on "Adventures of" and only knew ''Huck Finn''.
 +
 
 +
Because they usually contain few clues, speed-checks also may lack a clear [[giveaway]] and thus lead to dead tossups (while a more pyramidal question could provide more clues. For instance, in the HW Bush example, a more pyramidal question might end with "the father of George W." 
 +
 
 +
==Quasi-Pyramidal Speedchecks==
 +
It is possible to introduce elements of [[pyramidal]]ity into speedcheck questions. For instance:
 +
 
 +
Name the US President who hired "the Plumbers" and was responsible for the Saturday Night Massacre, which led to his impeachment and resignation in Watergate.
 +
 
 +
This is a very short question, but it contains:
 +
a. Several clues in rough order from harder to easier
 +
b. No misleading information or [[hose]]s
 +
c. A clear sense of what it is asking for (a US President) from the very start
 +
 
 +
Though a longer pyramidal question would be more ideal, this question is still roughly pyramidal. For television shows that often prefer shorter questions, pyramidal speed-checks can be an acceptable compromise.
 +
 
 +
 
 +
==Speedchecks in Bonus Rounds==
 +
Speed-check-style questions often appear in [[lightning rounds]], where it is usually more acceptable for them to be used as they can test a number of related points of knowledge quickly without leading to the issues inherent with buzzer races.  
  
 
[[Category:Bad quizbowl]]
 
[[Category:Bad quizbowl]]

Revision as of 02:38, 20 December 2016

Speed-check questions are very short questions in quizbowl, usually one sentence or less than a line in length. Such questions are rarely pyramidal due to their length and are usually considered (especially when sloppily written) bad quizbowl.

Notable users of speed-check questions include Questions Galore and many televised programs, such as Battle of the Brains and It's Academic.

Examples of Speedchecks

Speed-checks are usually bad quizbowl because they do not allow for players that know more about the topic to demonstrate that they know more by buzzing earlier. As the name implies, speed-check questions often reward the winner of a buzzer race rather than the player who recognized a fact first, a frustrating experience which occurs far less frequently when there are multiple clues to distinguish all players. For instance, a speed-check might go:

Name the 39th President of the United States.

or

Who wrote The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn?

These questions would both likely be considered bad quizbowl speed-checks. The former is due to asking about a relatively trivial fact rather than anything important about the actual life or presidency of George H.W. Bush, the latter due to not differentiating between players who have more knowledge of the material. In fact, a player who knows that there are other books that begin with "The Adventures of" (say, The Adventures of Augie March) might easily lose a buzzer race to a player who reflex-buzzed on "Adventures of" and only knew Huck Finn.

Because they usually contain few clues, speed-checks also may lack a clear giveaway and thus lead to dead tossups (while a more pyramidal question could provide more clues. For instance, in the HW Bush example, a more pyramidal question might end with "the father of George W."

Quasi-Pyramidal Speedchecks

It is possible to introduce elements of pyramidality into speedcheck questions. For instance:

Name the US President who hired "the Plumbers" and was responsible for the Saturday Night Massacre, which led to his impeachment and resignation in Watergate.

This is a very short question, but it contains: a. Several clues in rough order from harder to easier b. No misleading information or hoses c. A clear sense of what it is asking for (a US President) from the very start

Though a longer pyramidal question would be more ideal, this question is still roughly pyramidal. For television shows that often prefer shorter questions, pyramidal speed-checks can be an acceptable compromise.


Speedchecks in Bonus Rounds

Speed-check-style questions often appear in lightning rounds, where it is usually more acceptable for them to be used as they can test a number of related points of knowledge quickly without leading to the issues inherent with buzzer races.