Re: Quiz Bowl Upsets

Thus begins what Matt Colvin Said:

>In
1994, a team of Arthur Fleming, myself, Ram Kannappan,
and Misha Bernard (then M. Swisdak's girlfriend)
played at Philadelphia Experiment I.


<deletia>

>And Misha was not a quiz bowl player at all; she did
not attend practices or tournaments, and was only
playing to fill in our fourth seat and accompany Marc to
the tournament.

Thus ends what Matt Colvin
Said.

Not to denigrate the team's (I believe they went by
the name Noodle Noggin) accomplishment, but this
contains a slight inaccuracy. I still keep in contact in
Misha and thought she might be interested in her place
in Quiz Bowl history. After sending her Matt's post,
she offered the following, slight,
emendations.

1. She was not a complete layperson as she did
sporadically attend UMCP practices during 1993 and 1994,
although during that time (by her own choice), she did not
play at tournaments. In high school she had
occasionally played on her school's second team.

2. She
later went to graduate school at Chicago where she
attended practices although, again, not any
tournaments.

To what degree someone who has practiced but never
played in a tournament can be considered a layperson is
somewhat in doubt. Still, she was (by her own admission)
quite unwilling to buzz and a unlikely candidate to
pull down any tossups. Otherwise she agrees with
Matt's recollection --- Chicago played a horrible game,
taking a number of bad negs and inexplicably sitting on
several other questions. Matt and Arthur got the majority
of the team's tossups, but Misha and Ram picked up
two or three juicy nuggets of trash on the way to
victory.

Again, this takes essentially nothing away from the
upset's magnitude as Chicago was far and away the better
team in this match, at the tournament, and in the
country that year.

Marc Swisdak

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.4.0: Sat 12 Feb 2022 12:30:42 AM EST EST