Re: ACF Regionals West: brief results and comments

"In particular, one question comes to mind: the Australian 


geography bonus. The third part of that bonus asked for the second 


highest mountain in Australia (Mt. Townsend, if anyone cares). Now, 


I don't know squat about geography, but Jeff Hoppes's jaw dropped 


when he heard the question. My guess is that if he didn't know it, 


no one but the question writer probably knew the answer either."




Warning: This post may contain information which is of no interest to 
the reader.






Obviously, it is completely a matter of perspective whether or not
Mt. 
Townsend should be asked or not, but being the author of this 
particular bonus, I feel a certain need to defend it, especially
since 
it's been singled out from among the hundreds of bonuses in the set. 




For those who don't know or remember, the three parts of the bonus 
were: Murray River, Lake Eyre, Mt. Townsend. The Murray River is the 
longest river in Australia (one of two Australian rivers that are 
asked about), and Lake Eyre is the largest lake (when filled) in 
Australia (the only Australian lake ever asked about). Throw Mt. 
Kosciusko in there and you have perhaps the easiest possible bonus on 
Australian physical geography. I don't feel that this type of bonus 
would be appropriate for the usual target difficulty level of ACF 
Regionals.




"Importance" is certainly a silly term to throw around when talking 
about physical geography, at least in this case, since Kosciusko and 
Townsend are both basically big lumps of rock. You could say
Kosciusko 
is more "important" because it's the highest, but it's highest by
only 
about 50 feet. You could say it's more "important" because it's named 
after the Polish general, but according to the Columbia Encyclopedia 
(it has its own listing in there), Townsend used to be called Mt. 
Kosciusko, and was also thought to be the highest mountain in 
Australia for many years, so there is at least some historical 
significance there.




So that's my case for lovely and scenic Mt. Townsend. Perhaps when
you 
are writing your own Australian geography bonus, you will think back 
to this post and will have saved a little space in your heart for
this 
once mighty peak, now considered an also-ran by Jeff Hoppes and even 
Polish explorer Count Strzelecki. 




M. Lafer, "Michigan A"

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.4.0: Sat 12 Feb 2022 12:30:46 AM EST EST