Canon

From QBWiki
Jump to: navigation, search

The canon is the set of answers and clues which can be reasonably be expected to come up again in the future based on repeatedly coming in the past. It comprises much but not all of what one will hear in a given quizbowl packet. Being able to ask about an entirely new (and thus, non-canonical) topic in a way that does not compromise the accessibility of a question is a valuable skill for a writer and leads to some of the most well-received individual questions.

Canon expansion refers to the process of getting a subject into the canon by repeatedly mentioning it in packets.

Even within the circle of competent writers, there is much disagreement about what constitutes the canon and how much role canonicity should play in determining the difficulty of an answer. For example, an extremely canonical topic such as the works of William Dean Howells will be easy for any experienced player to answer, but may in fact be too difficult even for a fairly well-read person who is entirely new to quizbowl. Matt Weiner is a notable advocate of disregarding the canon as a formal means of evaluating accessibility in general-participation tournaments, and relying on actual predicted conversion rates as the sole criterion for selecting answers (while still recognizing a very high degree of crossover between canonical answers and accessible answers as the de facto reality). Ryan Westbrook and Jerry Vinokurov are among those who are more inclined to write based on what is canonical alone.

Important facts about the canon:

  • The canon shifts along with good quizbowl to exclude inane clues and non-real topics. Knowing who won various Nobel Prizes or what the professions of the fathers of famous people were used to be highly canonical; now, those clues are all but extinct, and thus are not canonical.
  • Subjects which are perfectly askable in good quizbowl drift in and out of the canon for other reasons or no reason. For example Ole Rolvaag used to be a staple of literature questions, but rarely is asked anymore. There was no particular agenda to drive Ole Rolvaag out of quizbowl; rather, it was simply an accident that no one wrote about him for some time.
  • There is little or no canon for trash, current events, general knowledge, or geography. This is partly due to the nature of those categories and partly due to who tends to write the most of them.
  • Finding non-canonical clues on canonical answers is the usual way to write easy questions in good quizbowl.
  • Becoming familiar with the canon is the best way to become a competent player; being able to predict and learn about the non-canonical answers that are on the cusp of being asked about is one way to become a great player.